Vaishnavism: Difference between revisions
Wiki-links. |
|||
Line 86: | Line 86: | ||
}}</ref> While many schools like [[Smartism]] and [[Advaita|Advaitism]] encourage interpretation of [[Hindu scripture|scriptures]] philosophically and metaphorically and not too literally,{{Citation needed|date=November 2009}} Vaishnavism stresses the literal meaning (''{{transl|sa|mukhya vṛitti}}'') as primary and indirect meaning (''{{transl|sa|gauṇa vṛitti}}'') as secondary: ''{{transl|sa|sākṣhād upadesas tu shrutih}}'' - "The instructions of the {{transl|sa|shruti-shāstra}} should be accepted literally, without ''fanciful or allegorical interpretations''."<ref name = "RG"/><ref>[[Jiva Goswami]], ''{{transl|sa|Kṛiṣhna}} Sandarbha'' 29.26-27</ref> |
}}</ref> While many schools like [[Smartism]] and [[Advaita|Advaitism]] encourage interpretation of [[Hindu scripture|scriptures]] philosophically and metaphorically and not too literally,{{Citation needed|date=November 2009}} Vaishnavism stresses the literal meaning (''{{transl|sa|mukhya vṛitti}}'') as primary and indirect meaning (''{{transl|sa|gauṇa vṛitti}}'') as secondary: ''{{transl|sa|sākṣhād upadesas tu shrutih}}'' - "The instructions of the {{transl|sa|shruti-shāstra}} should be accepted literally, without ''fanciful or allegorical interpretations''."<ref name = "RG"/><ref>[[Jiva Goswami]], ''{{transl|sa|Kṛiṣhna}} Sandarbha'' 29.26-27</ref> |
||
== |
== sampradayas== |
||
[[File:Iyengar Vedic students 1909.JPG|thumb|Vaishnavite Brahmin students at a theological seminary in [[Tanjore]]. Source:''The National Geographic Magazine'', Nov 1909]] |
[[File:Iyengar Vedic students 1909.JPG|thumb|Vaishnavite Brahmin students at a theological seminary in [[Tanjore]]. Source:''The National Geographic Magazine'', Nov 1909]] |
||
Within Vaishnavism there are four main disciplic lineages ([[sampradaya]]s),<ref>[http://content.iskcon.com/icj/4_1/satya_rsd.html The Sampradaya of Sri Caitanya, by Steven Rosen and William Deadwyler III] "the word sampradaya literally means 'a community'. A text from the Padma Purana quoted widely in Vaisnava writings speaks directly about these authorised communities. It says that 'Those mantras which are not received within a sampradaya are fruitless; they have no potency'. The text then specifically names the sampradayas. 'In the Kali-yuga, there will be four sampradayas.' ― we are talking about Vaisnava sampradayas ― 'They are the Brahma Sampradaya, originating with Brahma; Sri Sampradaya, starting with Laksmi; Rudra Sampradaya, starting with Siva; there's another one starting from Sanaka and the others, the Kumaras'. Those are the four recognised Vaisnava sampradayas."</ref> each exemplified by a specific Vedic personality. The four sampradayas follow subtly different philosophical systems regarding the relationship between the soul ([[jiva]]) and God ([[Vishnu]] or [[Krishna]]), although the majority of other core beliefs are identical.<ref name = "Mahony87"/><ref name = "RG"/><ref name = "KnottICJ">[http://web.uni-marburg.de/religionswissenschaft/journal/diskus/knott.html Contemporary Theological Trends in the Hare Krishna Movement] "Until the last fifteen years or so, there had been a lack of scholarship in the West on Vaishnavism, and this was seen by Hare Krishna devotees as a situation which must be changed."</ref><ref name=Beck2005>{{cite journal |
Within Vaishnavism there are four main disciplic lineages ([[sampradaya]]s),<ref>[http://content.iskcon.com/icj/4_1/satya_rsd.html The Sampradaya of Sri Caitanya, by Steven Rosen and William Deadwyler III] "the word sampradaya literally means 'a community'. A text from the Padma Purana quoted widely in Vaisnava writings speaks directly about these authorised communities. It says that 'Those mantras which are not received within a sampradaya are fruitless; they have no potency'. The text then specifically names the sampradayas. 'In the Kali-yuga, there will be four sampradayas.' ― we are talking about Vaisnava sampradayas ― 'They are the Brahma Sampradaya, originating with Brahma; Sri Sampradaya, starting with Laksmi; Rudra Sampradaya, starting with Siva; there's another one starting from Sanaka and the others, the Kumaras'. Those are the four recognised Vaisnava sampradayas."</ref> each exemplified by a specific Vedic personality. The four sampradayas follow subtly different philosophical systems regarding the relationship between the soul ([[jiva]]) and God ([[Vishnu]] or [[Krishna]]), although the majority of other core beliefs are identical.<ref name = "Mahony87"/><ref name = "RG"/><ref name = "KnottICJ">[http://web.uni-marburg.de/religionswissenschaft/journal/diskus/knott.html Contemporary Theological Trends in the Hare Krishna Movement] "Until the last fifteen years or so, there had been a lack of scholarship in the West on Vaishnavism, and this was seen by Hare Krishna devotees as a situation which must be changed."</ref><ref name=Beck2005>{{cite journal |
Revision as of 08:10, 19 March 2016
Part of a series on |
Vaishnavism |
---|
![]() |
Vaishnavism (Vaisnava dharma) is one of the major branches of Hinduism along with Shaivism, Shaktism, and Smartism. It is focused on the veneration of Vishnu. Vaishnavites, or the followers of the Vishnu, lead a way of life promoting the central importance of Vishnu and his ten avatars.
Followers worship Vishnu, the Supreme Lord and preserver of the Hindu Trimurti ('three images', the Trinity), and his ten avatars, including Rama and Krishna. The adherents of this sect are generally monastic[citation needed] and devoted to meditative practice and ecstatic chanting.[1][2][3] They are deeply devotional. Vaishnavism is rich in saints, temples and scriptures.[4]
Its beliefs and practices, especially the concepts of Bhakti and Bhakti Yoga, are based largely on the Upanishads, and associated with the Vedas and Puranic texts such as the Bhagavad Gita, and the Padma Purana, Vishnu Purana and Bhagavata Purana.[5][6][7][8]
Principal historic branches
Bhagavatism, early Ramaism and Krishnaism merged in historical Vishnuism,[9] a tradition of historical Vedic religion, distinguished from other traditions by its primary worship of Vishnu.[10] Vaishnavism is historically the first structured Vaishnava religion as "Vishnuism, in a word, is the only cultivated native sectarian religion of India."[11] Although it is usual to speak of Vishnu as the source of the Avatar, this is only one of the names by which the god of Vaishnavism is known. The other names include Narayana, Vasudeva, Rama and Krishna; each the name of a divine figure with attributed supremacy, which each associated tradition of Vaishnavism believes to be distinct.[12] For example, in the Krishnaism branch of Vaishnavism,[13] such as the Gaudiya Vaishnava, Nimbarka and Vallabhacharya traditions, devotees worship Krishna as the One Supreme form of God, and source of all avatars, Svayam Bhagavan, in contrast to the belief of the devotees of the Sri Sampradaya.[14]
Principal beliefs
Part of a series on |
Hinduism |
---|
![]() |
Supreme God
The principal belief of Vishnu-centered sects is the identification of Vishnu or Narayana as the one supreme God. This belief is similar to Krishna-centered traditions, such as Nimbaraka and Vallabha, in which Krishna is considered as the Supreme Lord Vishnu.
The belief in the supremacy of Vishnu is based upon the many avatars (incarnations) of Vishnu listed in the Puranic texts, which differs from other Hindu deities such as Ganesha, Surya or Durga. According to many Vaishnavites, the latter are instead classified as demi-gods or devas.
Initiation
Vaishnavas, in following the process of initiation (diksha) given by a guru under whom they are trained to understand Vaishnava practices, accept the importance of the Supremacy of Lord Vishnu. At the time of initiation, the disciple is traditionally given a specific mantra, which the disciple will repeat, either out loud or within the mind, as an act of worship to Vishnu or one of his avatars. The practice of repetitive prayer is known as japa. The system of receiving initiation and training from a guru is based on injunctions throughout the scriptures held as sacred within the Vaishnava traditions but is not mandatory:
- "Just try to learn the truth by approaching a spiritual master. Inquire from him submissively and render service unto him. The self-realized souls can impart knowledge unto you because they have seen the truth." (Bhagavad Gita)[15]
- "One who is initiated into the Vaishnava mantra and who is devoted to worshiping Lord Vishnu is a Vaishnava. One who is devoid of these practices is not a Vaishnava." (Padma Purana)[16]
The scriptures specific to the Gaudiya Vaishnava group also state that one who performs an act of worship as simple as chanting the name of Vishnu or Krishna can be considered a Vaishnava by practice:
- "Who chants the holy name of Krishna just once may be considered a Vaishnava. Such a person is worship-able and is the topmost human being." (Chaitanya Charitamrita)[17]
Attitude toward scriptures
Vaishnava traditions refer to the writings of previous acharyas in their respective lineage or sampradya (see below) as authoritative interpretations of scripture.[18] While many schools like Smartism and Advaitism encourage interpretation of scriptures philosophically and metaphorically and not too literally,[citation needed] Vaishnavism stresses the literal meaning (mukhya vṛitti) as primary and indirect meaning (gauṇa vṛitti) as secondary: sākṣhād upadesas tu shrutih - "The instructions of the shruti-shāstra should be accepted literally, without fanciful or allegorical interpretations."[18][19]
SriVaishnava sampradayas
Within Vaishnavism there are four main disciplic lineages (sampradayas),[20] each exemplified by a specific Vedic personality. The four sampradayas follow subtly different philosophical systems regarding the relationship between the soul (jiva) and God (Vishnu or Krishna), although the majority of other core beliefs are identical.[5][18][21][22]
- Sri Sampradaya which is the Sampradaya of Lakshmi
- Philosophy: Vishishtadvaita ("Qualified Monoism"), espoused by Chidachida Visishtam Ramanujacharya
- See Sri Vaishnavism, Vaikhanasa, Ramanandi Sect.
- Brahma sampradaya
- Philosophies: Dvaita ("dualism"), espoused by Madhvacharya, and Achintya Bheda Abheda (literally "inconceivable difference and non-difference").
- Rudra sampradaya
- Philosophy: Shuddhadvaita ("pure nondualism"), espoused by Vishnuswami and Vallabhacharya.
- Kumara-sampradaya
- Philosophy: Dvaitadvaita ("duality in unity"), espoused by Nimbarka.[23]
Vaishnavism in South India
Broadly, Vaishnavas in South India can be classified as Brahmins and non-Brahmins.
Among the Brahmins the main groups are:
- The Iyengars, who follow the Sri Vaishnava Vishistadvaita philosophy of Asuri Ramanujacharya. The Iyengars are further divided into the Vadakalai-i.e. the northern school, and Thenkalai or southern school. Both these sects adhere to the Pañcaratra agama, in temples.
These two sects evolved about 200 years after Ramanuja and differ on 18 points of doctrine. The founder of the Vadagalai sect is Swami Vedanta Desika, and the Tengalai sect is Manavala Mamuni.[24] But both schools have a common Guru Parampara prior to the division. The Sri Vaishnavas use both the Sanskrit veda as well as the Tamil divyaprabandham in temple worship.
- The Madhvas, who follow the Sadvaishnava Dvaita philosophy of Madhvacharya.
The Vaikhanasas, who are primarily an ancient community of temple priests, who use the Vaikhanasa Agama in temple worship. They use Sanskrit exclusively in temple worship.
Among the non-Brahmins :
- Namadhari Naik in Karnataka
- Chettiars and Mudaliars (Thuluva Vellalars)in Tamil Nadu
- Komati Caste, Kammas, Padmashalis, Reddys, Rajus and Haridasus in Andhra Pradesh
- Velamas in Telangana state
Some groups tend to be vegetarians like the Brahmins.
In temple worship, a Vaikhanasa temple (like Tirumala), a Madhva temple (like Udupi), a Tengalai temple (like Melukote) and a Vadagalai temple (like Thiruvallur) all have distinctly different rituals and customs with priests of that particular denomination who perform the worship. However all temples are popularly visited by all Vaishnavas as lay worshippers, as also members of various other denominations.
In Kerala, some communities call themselves Vaishnavas, especially the pisharodies and Gauda Saraswatha Brahmins and Embranthiries who settled in Kerala at a later phase of Brahmin Settlement. The Sagara Brahmins in and around Thiruvalla Sree Vallabha Vishnu Temple are also referred to as Vaisnavas accepting the Supremacy of Lord Vishnu.
Other branches and sects
On my tongue Vishnu, in my eyes Narayana, in my heart dwells Govinda.
— Adi Granth, IV.XXV.I
- Charan Dasi, founded by Charan Das a Dhusar of Dehra
- Lalpanthi Sampradaya or Lal Dasi sect, founded by Laldas a Meo of Dhaoli Dub
- Madhwachari sect
- Mahapuruxiya Dharma, espoused by Sankardeva
- Mohan Panth
- Nimbhawat sect
- Pranami sect
- The Ramanandi movement, begun by Ramananda
- Ramawat sect
- Vaisnava-Sahajiya, a tantric school
Tilaka styles
Vaishnavas mark their foreheads with tilaka, either as a daily ritual, or on special occasions. The different Vaishnava sampradayas each have their own distinctive style of tilaka, which depicts the siddhanta of their particular lineage. The general tilaka pattern is of a parabolic shape resembling the letter U or two or more connected vertical lines on and another optional line on the nose resembling the letter Y, which usually represents the foot of Vishnu and the centre vertical line symbolizing his manhood. Alternate interpretations suggest that the symbol in representation of male and female parts in union.[26][27]
History
Vaishnavism is the largest denomination of Hinduism,with almost 350 million followers.[28] The worship of Vishnu was already well developed in the period of the Itihasas.[29] Hopkins says "Vishnuism, in a word, is the only cultivated native sectarian religion of India."[11] Vaishnavism is expounded in a part of the Mahabharata known as the Bhagavad Gita, which contains a dialogue between Krishna and Arjuna. In this dialogue, Krishna plays the role of Arjuna's charioteer.
Many of the ancient kings, beginning with Chandragupta II (Vikramaditya) (375-413 CE) were known as Parama Bhagavatas or Bhagavata Vaishnavas.[30]
Vaishnavism flourished in predominantly Shaivite South India during the seventh to tenth centuries CE and is still commonplace, especially in Tamil Nadu, as a result of the twelve Alvars, saints who spread the sect to the common people with their devotional hymns. The temples that the Alvars visited or founded are now known as Divya Desams. Their poems in praise of Vishnu and Krishna in Tamil language are collectively known as Naalayira (Divya Prabandha).[31][32]
In later years, Vaishnava practices increased in popularity due to the influence of sages like Ramanujacharya, Madhvacharya, Nimbarkacharya, Vallabhacharya, Vedanta Desika, Manavala Mamunigal, Surdas, Tulsidas, eknath, Tyagaraja, and many others.[33][34][35][36]
In his The Religions of India, Edward Washburn Hopkins presents an accepted distinction as to the assumption that Vishnuism is associated with Vedic brahmanism, and was part of brahmanism. Krishnaism was adopted much later, and it is for this reason, amongst others, that despite its modern iniquities Shiva has appealed more to the brahmans than Krishna. It's only later that Vishnuism merged with Krishnaism.[37] Thus, today Vashnavism is by far the most popular sect of Hinduism, having more followers than Shaivism and Shaktaism combined.[citation needed]
Large Vaishnava communities exist throughout India, and particularly in Western Indian states, such as western Madhya Pradesh, Rajasthan Maharashtra and Gujarat. Important sites of pilgrimage for Vaishnavs include Guruvayur Temple, Sri Rangam, Vrindavan, Mathura, Ayodhya, Tirupati, Pandharpur (Vitthal), Puri (Jaggannath), Mayapur, Nathdwara and Dwarka.[38][39]
During the 20th century, Vaishnavism has spread from India and is now practiced in many places around the globe, including North America, Europe, Africa, Russia and South America. This is largely due to the growth of the ISKCON movement, founded by A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupada in 1966.[40][41][42]
Puranic epics
Two great Indian epics, the Ramayana and the Mahabharata, form an important part of Vaishnava philosophy, theology, and culture.
The Ramayana describes the story of Rama, an avatara of Vishnu, and is taken as a history of the 'ideal king', based on the principles of dharma, morality and ethics. Rama's wife Sita, his brother Lakshman, with his devotee and follower Hanuman all play key roles within the Vaishnava tradition as examples of Vaishnava etiquette and behaviour. Ravana, the evil king and villain of the epic, plays the opposite role of how not to behave.
The Mahabharata is centered around Krishna and details the story of a dynastic war between two families of cousins, with Krishna and the Pandavas, five brothers, playing pivotal roles in the drama. The philosophical highlight of the work is the chapter covering a conversation between Arjuna and Krishna prior to the final battle, individually known as the Bhagavad Gita. The Bhagavad Gita, though influential in most philosophies of Hinduism, is of particular importance to Vaishnavas because it is believed to be an accurate record of the very words spoken by Krishna himself. Both works are often re-enacted in part as dramas by followers of Vaishnavism, especially on festival days concerning each of the specific avatars. The Bhagavad Gita is widely studied as a theological textbook and is rendered in numerous English translations and world languages.
Academic study
Vaishnava theology has been a subject of study and debate for many devotees, philosophers and scholars within India for centuries. In recent decades this study has also been pursued in a number of academic institutions in Europe, such as the Oxford Centre for Hindu Studies, Bhaktivedanta College, and Syanandura Vaishnava Sabha, a moderate and progressive Vaishnava body headed by Gautham Padmanabhan in Trivandrum which intends to bring about a single and precise book called Hari-grantha to include all Vaishnava philosophies.
See also
References
- ^ "ISKCON". Retrieved 7 February 2014.
- ^ "Hindus in SA". Retrieved 7 February 2014.
- ^ Dubois (1 April 2007). Hindu Manners, Customs and Ceremonies. Cosimo. p. 111. ISBN 9781602063365.
- ^ "HimalayanAcademy". Retrieved 7 February 2014.
- ^ a b Mahony, W.K. (1987). "Perspectives on Krsna's Various Personalities". History of Religions. 26 (3): 333–335. doi:10.1086/463085. JSTOR 1062381.
- ^ Elkman, S.M.; Gosvami, J. (1986). Jiva Gosvamin's Tattvasandarbha: A Study on the Philosophical and Sectarian Development of the Gaudiya Vaisnava Movement. Motilal Banarsidass Pub.
- ^ Heart of Hinduism - Vaishnavism
- ^ Explanation of different scriptural texts within Hinduism
- ^ Jan Gonda (1993). Aspects of Early Visnuism. Motilal Banarsidass Publ. p. 163. ISBN 978-81-208-1087-7.
- ^ Goswami, B.K. (1965). The Bhakti Cult in Ancient India. Chowkhamba Sanskrit Series Office.
- ^ a b Hopkins,The Religions of India, p.690
- ^ Matchett, Freda (2000). Krsna, Lord or Avatara? the relationship between Lord Krishna and Lord Vishnu: in the context of the Avatara myth as presented by the Harivamsa, the Visnupurana and the Bhagavatapurana. Surrey: Routledge. p. 254. ISBN 0-7007-1281-X. p. 4
- ^ Review: by Kenneth Scott Latourette India and Christendom: The Historical Connections between Their Religions. by Richard Garbe; Lydia Gillingham Robinson Pacific Affairs, Vol. 34, No. 3 (Autumn, 1961), pp. 317-318.
- ^ Page 1–Ramanuja and Sri Vaisnavism "In general, the Vaishnava Agamas describe Lord Vishnu is the Supreme Being and the foundation of all existence."
- ^ Bhag Gita 4:34
- ^ Caitanya Caritamrta: Madhya-lila, 15.106, 16.72, 16.74
- ^ Chaitanya Charitamrita: Madhya-lila, 15.106
- ^ a b c Gupta, Ravi M.; Edited by Gavin Flood, University of Stirling (2007). Caitanya Vaisnava Vedanta of Jiva Gosvami: When knowledge meets devotion. Routledge. ISBN 0-415-40548-3.
{{cite book}}
:|author2=
has generic name (help) - ^ Jiva Goswami, Kṛiṣhna Sandarbha 29.26-27
- ^ The Sampradaya of Sri Caitanya, by Steven Rosen and William Deadwyler III "the word sampradaya literally means 'a community'. A text from the Padma Purana quoted widely in Vaisnava writings speaks directly about these authorised communities. It says that 'Those mantras which are not received within a sampradaya are fruitless; they have no potency'. The text then specifically names the sampradayas. 'In the Kali-yuga, there will be four sampradayas.' ― we are talking about Vaisnava sampradayas ― 'They are the Brahma Sampradaya, originating with Brahma; Sri Sampradaya, starting with Laksmi; Rudra Sampradaya, starting with Siva; there's another one starting from Sanaka and the others, the Kumaras'. Those are the four recognised Vaisnava sampradayas."
- ^ Contemporary Theological Trends in the Hare Krishna Movement "Until the last fifteen years or so, there had been a lack of scholarship in the West on Vaishnavism, and this was seen by Hare Krishna devotees as a situation which must be changed."
- ^ Guy L. Beck (2005). "Krishna as Loving Husband of God". Alternative Krishnas: Regional and Vernacular Variations on a Hindu Deity. ISBN 978-0-7914-6415-1. Retrieved 12 April 2008.
- ^ Klostermaier, K.K. (1998). A concise encyclopedia of Hinduism. Oneworld.
- ^ Chari, S.M Srinivasa (1997). Philosophy and Theistic Mysticism of the Alvars. New Delhi: Motilal Banarsidass. p. 224.
- ^ P. 661 The Ādi-Granth, Or: The Holy Scriptures of the Sikhs edited by Ernst Trumpp
- ^ britannica.com Vaishnavism
- ^ http://www.stephen-knapp.com/tilak_why_wear_it.htm
- ^ http://www.patheos.com/Library/Vaishnavite-Hinduism.html
- ^ britannica.com
- ^ Kalyan Kumar Ganguli (1988). Sraddh njali, Studies in Ancient Indian History: D.C. Sircar Commemoration: Puranic tradition of Krishna. Sundeep Prakashan. ISBN 81-85067-10-4.p.36
- ^ Annangaracariyar, P.B. (1971). Nalayira tivviyap pirapantam. Kanci: VN Tevanatan.
- ^ Seth, K.P. (1962). "Bhakti in Alvar Saints". The University Journal of Philosophy.
- ^ Jackson, W.J. (1992). "A Life Becomes a Legend: Sri Tyagaraja as Exemplar". Journal of the American Academy of Religion. 60 (4): 717–736. doi:10.1093/jaarel/lx.4.717. JSTOR 1465591.
- ^ Jackson, W.J. (1991). Tyagaraja: Life and Lyrics. Oxford University Press, USA.
- ^ Ayyappapanicker, K.; Akademi, S. (2000). Medieval Indian Literature: An Anthology. Sahitya Akademi.
- ^ Roy Chaudhury, H.C.; Prajnananda, S. (2002). "Further Reading". Encyclopedia of Modern Asia.
- ^ Hopkins,The Religions of India, p.530 "When, however, pantheism, nay, even Vishnuism, or still more, Krishnaism, was an accepted fact upon what, then, was the wisdom of the priest expended?"
- ^ Klostermaier, Klaus K. (2000). Hinduism: A Short History. Oxford: Oneworld Publications. ISBN 1-85168-213-9.
- ^ Valpey, K.R. (2004). The Grammar and Poetics of Murti-Seva: Caitanya Vaisnava Image Worship as Discourse, Ritual, and Narrative. University of Oxford.
- ^ Selengut, Charles (1996). "Charisma and Religious Innovation:Prabhupada and the Founding of ISKCON". ISKCON Communications Journal. 4 (2). Archived from the original on 13 July 2011.
{{cite journal}}
: Unknown parameter|deadurl=
ignored (|url-status=
suggested) (help) - ^ Herzig, T.; Valpey, K (2004). "Re—visioning Iskcon". The Hare Krishna Movement: the Postcharismatic Fate of a Religious Transplant. ISBN 978-0-231-12256-6. Retrieved 10 January 2008.
- ^ Prabhupada - He Built a House, Satsvarupa dasa Goswami, Bhaktivedanta Book Trust, 1983, ISBN 0-89213-133-0 p. xv
External links
- Vaishnavism (Tradition of Hinduism)
- Vaishnavism (Heart of Hinduism)
- Who is Vishnu? Vaishnava FAQ (dvaita.org)
- Nathamuni-Alavandar.org - Dedicated to Shriman Nathamunigal and Shri Alavandar
- Portal for Vaishnav An Exclusive Portal dedicated to Vaishnavism
- Portal for Vaishnavism eClass Online elearning of Divya prabandham by themes.
- [1] Sudarsanar refutes the idea of Ramalingam