-
Big-bang Nucleosynthesis Enters the Precision Era
Authors:
David N. Schramm,
Michael S. Turner
Abstract:
The last parameter of big-bang nucleosynthesis, the baryon density, is being pinned down by measurements of the deuterium abundance in high-redshift hydrogen clouds. When it is determined, it will fix the primeval light-element abundances. D, ^3He and ^7Li will become ``tracers'' for the study of Galactic and stellar chemical evolution, and big-bang nucleosynthesis will become an even sharper pr…
▽ More
The last parameter of big-bang nucleosynthesis, the baryon density, is being pinned down by measurements of the deuterium abundance in high-redshift hydrogen clouds. When it is determined, it will fix the primeval light-element abundances. D, ^3He and ^7Li will become ``tracers'' for the study of Galactic and stellar chemical evolution, and big-bang nucleosynthesis will become an even sharper probe of particle physics, e.g., the bound to the number of light neutrino species will be tightened significantly. Two key tests of the consistency of the standard theory are on the horizon: an independent, high-precision determination of the baryon density from anisotropy of the cosmic background radiation and a precision determination of the primeval $^4$He abundance.
△ Less
Submitted 7 June, 1997;
originally announced June 1997.
-
Ultra-high energy cosmic ray sources and large scale magnetic fields
Authors:
Martin Lemoine,
Guenter Sigl,
Angela V. Olinto,
David N. Schramm
Abstract:
Protons of energies up to 10**20 eV can be subject to significant deflection and energy dependent time delay in lage scale extragalactic or halo magnetic fields of strengths comparable to current upper limits. By performing 3-dimensional Monte Carlo simulations of nucleon propagation, we show how observations of arrival direction and time distributions can be used to measure the structure and st…
▽ More
Protons of energies up to 10**20 eV can be subject to significant deflection and energy dependent time delay in lage scale extragalactic or halo magnetic fields of strengths comparable to current upper limits. By performing 3-dimensional Monte Carlo simulations of nucleon propagation, we show how observations of arrival direction and time distributions can be used to measure the structure and strength of large-scale magnetic fields, and constrain the nature of the source of ultra-high energy cosmic rays.
△ Less
Submitted 21 April, 1997;
originally announced April 1997.
-
Deuteronomy and Numbers
Authors:
David N. Schramm,
Michael S. Turner
Abstract:
Four light isotopes - D, ^3He, ^4He and ^7Li - were produced by nuclear reactions a few seconds after the big bang. New measurements of ^3He in the ISM by Gloeckler and Geiss and of deuterium in high redshift hydrogen clouds by Tytler and his collaborators provide further confirmation of big-bang nucleosynthesis and new insight about the density of ordinary matter (baryons).
Four light isotopes - D, ^3He, ^4He and ^7Li - were produced by nuclear reactions a few seconds after the big bang. New measurements of ^3He in the ISM by Gloeckler and Geiss and of deuterium in high redshift hydrogen clouds by Tytler and his collaborators provide further confirmation of big-bang nucleosynthesis and new insight about the density of ordinary matter (baryons).
△ Less
Submitted 25 March, 1997;
originally announced March 1997.
-
A Fresh Look at Axions and SN 1987A
Authors:
Wolfgang Keil,
Hans-Thomas Janka,
David N. Schramm,
Guenter Sigl,
Michael S. Turner,
John Ellis
Abstract:
We re-examine the very stringent limits on the axion mass based on the strength and duration of the neutrino signal from SN 1987A, in the light of new measurements of the axial-vector coupling strength of nucleons, possible suppression of axion emission due to many-body effects, and additional emission processes involving pions. The suppression of axion emission due to nucleon spin fluctuations…
▽ More
We re-examine the very stringent limits on the axion mass based on the strength and duration of the neutrino signal from SN 1987A, in the light of new measurements of the axial-vector coupling strength of nucleons, possible suppression of axion emission due to many-body effects, and additional emission processes involving pions. The suppression of axion emission due to nucleon spin fluctuations induced by many-body effects degrades previous limits by a factor of about 2. Emission processes involving thermal pions can strengthen the limits by a factor of 3-4 within a perturbative treatment that neglects saturation of nucleon spin fluctuations. Inclusion of saturation effects, however, tends to make the limits less dependent on pion abundances. The resulting axion mass limit also depends on the precise couplings of the axion and ranges from 0.5x10**(-3) eV to 6x10**(-3) eV.
△ Less
Submitted 23 December, 1996;
originally announced December 1996.
-
Nuclear Reaction Rates and Primordial $^6$Li
Authors:
Kenneth M. Nollett,
Martin Lemoine,
David N. Schramm
Abstract:
We examine the possibility that Big Bang Nucleosynthesis (BBN) may produce non-trivial amounts of $^6$Li. If a primordial component of this isotope could be observed, it would provide a new fundamental test of Big-Bang cosmology, as well as new constraints on the baryon density of the universe. At present, however, theoretical predictions of the primordial $^6$Li abundance are extremely uncertai…
▽ More
We examine the possibility that Big Bang Nucleosynthesis (BBN) may produce non-trivial amounts of $^6$Li. If a primordial component of this isotope could be observed, it would provide a new fundamental test of Big-Bang cosmology, as well as new constraints on the baryon density of the universe. At present, however, theoretical predictions of the primordial $^6$Li abundance are extremely uncertain due to difficulties in both theoretical estimates and experimental determinations of the deuterium-plus-alpha radiative capture reaction cross-section. We also argue that present observational capabilities do not yet allow the detection of primeval $^6$Li in very metal-poor stars of the galactic halo. However, if the critical cross section is towards the upper end of its plausible range, then improvements in $^6$Li detection capabilities may allow the establishment of $^6$Li as another product of BBN. It is also noted that a primordial $^6$Li detection could help resolve current concerns about the extragalactic D/H determination.
△ Less
Submitted 19 December, 1996;
originally announced December 1996.
-
Cosmological Neutrino Signatures for Grand Unification Scale Physics
Authors:
Guenter Sigl,
Sangjin Lee,
David N. Schramm,
Paolo Coppi
Abstract:
Physics beyond the standard model might imply the cosmological production of particles with grand unification scale energies. Nucleons and gamma-rays from such processes are candidates for the cosmic rays observed beyond 100 EeV [10**(20) eV]. Using a new particle propagation code, we calculate the neutrino fluxes predicted by such scenarios if consistency with the observed cosmic ray flux and t…
▽ More
Physics beyond the standard model might imply the cosmological production of particles with grand unification scale energies. Nucleons and gamma-rays from such processes are candidates for the cosmic rays observed beyond 100 EeV [10**(20) eV]. Using a new particle propagation code, we calculate the neutrino fluxes predicted by such scenarios if consistency with the observed cosmic ray flux and the universal gamma-ray background at 1-10 GeV is required. Flux levels detectable by proposed km**3 scale neutrino observatories are allowed by these constraints. Bounds on or detection of a neutrino flux above about 1 EeV would allow neutrino astronomy to probe grand unification scale physics.
△ Less
Submitted 27 October, 1996;
originally announced October 1996.
-
On the significance of population II Li6 abundances
Authors:
M. Lemoine,
D. N. Schramm,
J. W. Truran,
C. J. Copi
Abstract:
We explore possible depletion factors for Li6 in the three stars where it has been detected. To this end, we assume that 6Li/H scales as 16O/H throughout the galactic evolution, an assumption motivated by the observations of a similar scaling for 9Be. We examine the uncertainties attached to this modeling of 6Li galactic evolution; we also incorporate a recent evaluation of the primordial produc…
▽ More
We explore possible depletion factors for Li6 in the three stars where it has been detected. To this end, we assume that 6Li/H scales as 16O/H throughout the galactic evolution, an assumption motivated by the observations of a similar scaling for 9Be. We examine the uncertainties attached to this modeling of 6Li galactic evolution; we also incorporate a recent evaluation of the primordial production of 6Li. The depletion factor D6, for 6Li, in HD84937, is constrained to be less than 4 at 95% c.l.. This depletion factor is an extreme upper limit on the depletion factor for 7Li. We conclude that the primordial abundance of 7Li cannot be higher that twice the observed value, since no current stellar model is able to reproduce the observed trends of 7Li with temperature and metallicity, and yet deplete 7Li by more than a factor 2, while satisfying D6<4. All three 6Li observations are in excellent agreement with all standard expectations: Big-Bang nucleosynthesis with 2<$η_{10}$<6.5, and standard isochrones of 6Li survival. We discuss possible deviations from our assumption of 6Li/H scaling with 16O/H, due to alpha-alpha creation of 6Li in various sites. We notably reject stellar flares as a significant source of 6Li in HD84937.
△ Less
Submitted 13 October, 1996;
originally announced October 1996.
-
Low Mass Stars and the He3 Problem
Authors:
Keith A. Olive,
D. N. Schramm,
Sean Scully,
J. W. Truran
Abstract:
The prediction of standard chemical evolution models of higher abundances of He3 at the solar and present-day epochs than are observed indicates a possible problem with the yield of He3 for stars in the range of 1-3 solar masses. Because He3 is one of the nuclei produced in Big Bang Nucleosynthesis (BBN), it is noted that galactic and stellar evolution uncertainties necessarily relax constraints…
▽ More
The prediction of standard chemical evolution models of higher abundances of He3 at the solar and present-day epochs than are observed indicates a possible problem with the yield of He3 for stars in the range of 1-3 solar masses. Because He3 is one of the nuclei produced in Big Bang Nucleosynthesis (BBN), it is noted that galactic and stellar evolution uncertainties necessarily relax constraints based on He3. We incorporate into chemical evolution models which include outflow, the new yields for He3 of Boothroyd & Malaney (1995) which predict that low mass stars are net destroyers of He3. Since these yields do not account for the high \he3/H ratio observed in some planetary nebulae, we also consider the possibility that some fraction of stars in the 1 - 3 solar mass range do not destroy their He3 in theirpost main-sequence phase. We also consider the possibility that the gas expelled by stars in these mass ranges does not mix with the ISM instantaneously thus delaying the He3 produced in these stars, according to standard yields, from reaching the ISM. In general, we find that the Galactic D and He3 abundances can be fit regardless of whether the primordial D/H value is high (2 x 10^{-4}) or low (2.5 x 10^{-5}).
△ Less
Submitted 4 October, 1996;
originally announced October 1996.
-
Constraints on the Strength of Primordial Magnetic Fields from Big Bang Nucleosynthesis Revisited
Authors:
Baolian Cheng,
Angela V. Olinto,
David N. Schramm,
James W. Truran
Abstract:
In this paper, we revisit in detail the effects of primordial magnetic fields on big bang nucleosynthesis (BBN) including a discussion of the magnetic field geometry and the anomalous magnetic moment. The presence of magnetic fields affects BBN by (1) increasing the weak reaction rates; (2) increasing the electron density due to changes to the electron phase space; and (3) by increasing the expa…
▽ More
In this paper, we revisit in detail the effects of primordial magnetic fields on big bang nucleosynthesis (BBN) including a discussion of the magnetic field geometry and the anomalous magnetic moment. The presence of magnetic fields affects BBN by (1) increasing the weak reaction rates; (2) increasing the electron density due to changes to the electron phase space; and (3) by increasing the expansion rate of the universe, due both to the magnetic field energy density and to the modified electron energy density. Of the effects considered, the increase in the expansion rate due to the magnetic field energy is the most significant for the interests of BBN. The allowed magnetic field intensity at the end of nucleosynthesis (0.01 MeV) is about $2 \times 10^{9}$G and corresponds to an upper limit on the magnetic field energy density of about 28\% of the neutrino energy density ($ρ_B \le 0.28 ρ_ν$).
△ Less
Submitted 26 June, 1996;
originally announced June 1996.
-
Implications of a Primordial Origin for the Dispersion in D/H in Quasar Absorption Systems
Authors:
Craig J Copi,
Keith A. Olive,
David N. Schramm
Abstract:
We consider possible implications if the recent and disconcordant measurements of D/H in quasar absorption systems are real and indicate a dispersion in D/H in these primitive systems. In particular we examine the option that the D/H abundances in these systems, which are separated on cosmological scales, are primordial, implying a large scale inhomogeneity in the baryon content of the Universe.…
▽ More
We consider possible implications if the recent and disconcordant measurements of D/H in quasar absorption systems are real and indicate a dispersion in D/H in these primitive systems. In particular we examine the option that the D/H abundances in these systems, which are separated on cosmological scales, are primordial, implying a large scale inhomogeneity in the baryon content of the Universe. We show that such large scale isocurvature perturbations are excluded by current cosmic microwave background observations. We also discuss the implications of a smaller (in amplitude) inhomogeneity on the problem of the baryon density in clusters.
△ Less
Submitted 25 June, 1996;
originally announced June 1996.
-
The Big-Bang Nucleosynthesis Limit to the Number of Neutrino Species
Authors:
Craig J Copi,
David N. Schramm,
Michael S. Turner
Abstract:
Concern about systematic uncertainty in the $^4$He abundance as well as the chemical evolution of $^3$He leads us to re-examine this important limit. It is shown that with conservative assumptions no more than the equivalent of 4 massless neutrino species are allowed. Even with the most extreme estimates of the astrophysical uncertainties a meaningful limit still exists, less than 5 massless neu…
▽ More
Concern about systematic uncertainty in the $^4$He abundance as well as the chemical evolution of $^3$He leads us to re-examine this important limit. It is shown that with conservative assumptions no more than the equivalent of 4 massless neutrino species are allowed. Even with the most extreme estimates of the astrophysical uncertainties a meaningful limit still exists, less than 5 massless neutrino species, and illustrates the robustness of this argument. A definitive measurement of the deuterium abundance in high-redshift hydrogen clouds should soon sharpen the limit.
△ Less
Submitted 10 June, 1996;
originally announced June 1996.
-
Implications of a Possible Clustering of Highest Energy Cosmic Rays
Authors:
Guenter Sigl,
David N. Schramm,
Sangjin Lee,
Paolo Coppi,
Christopher T. Hill
Abstract:
Very recently, a possible clustering of a subset of observed ultrahigh energy cosmic rays above about 40EeV (4x10^19eV) in pairs near the supergalactic plane was reported. We show that a confirmation of this effect would provide information on origin and nature of these events and, in case of charged primaries, imply interesting constraints on the extragalactic magnetic field. The observed time…
▽ More
Very recently, a possible clustering of a subset of observed ultrahigh energy cosmic rays above about 40EeV (4x10^19eV) in pairs near the supergalactic plane was reported. We show that a confirmation of this effect would provide information on origin and nature of these events and, in case of charged primaries, imply interesting constraints on the extragalactic magnetic field. The observed time correlation would most likely rule out an association of these events with cosmological gamma ray bursts. If no prominent astrophysical source candidates such as powerful radiogalaxies can be found, the existence of a mechanism involving new fundamental physics would be favored.
△ Less
Submitted 25 May, 1996;
originally announced May 1996.
-
Geological Isotope Anomalies as Signatures of Nearby Supernovae
Authors:
John Ellis,
Brian D. Fields,
David N. Schramm
Abstract:
Nearby supernova explosions may cause geological isotope anomalies via the direct deposition of debris or by cosmic-ray spallation in the earth's atmosphere. We estimate the mass of material deposited terrestrially by these two mechanisms, showing the dependence on the supernova distance. A number of radioactive isotopes are identified as possible diagnostic tools, such as Be-10, Al-26, Cl-36, M…
▽ More
Nearby supernova explosions may cause geological isotope anomalies via the direct deposition of debris or by cosmic-ray spallation in the earth's atmosphere. We estimate the mass of material deposited terrestrially by these two mechanisms, showing the dependence on the supernova distance. A number of radioactive isotopes are identified as possible diagnostic tools, such as Be-10, Al-26, Cl-36, Mn-53, Fe-60, and Ni-59, as well as the longer-lived I-129, Sm-146, and Pu-244. We discuss whether the 35 and 60 kyr-old Be-10 anomalies observed in the Vostok antarctic ice cores could be due to supernova explosions. Combining our estimates for matter deposition with results of recent nucleosynthesis yields, we calculate the expected signal from nearby supernovae using ice cores back to $\sim 300$ kyr ago, and we discuss using deep ocean sediments back to several hundred Myr. In particular, we examine the prospects for identifying isotope anomalies due to the Geminga supernova explosion, and signatures of the possibility that supernovae might have caused one or more biological mass extinctions.
△ Less
Submitted 20 May, 1996;
originally announced May 1996.
-
Halo White Dwarfs and the Hot Intergalactic Medium
Authors:
Brian D. Fields,
Grant J. Mathews,
David N. Schramm
Abstract:
We present a schematic model for the formation of baryonic galactic halos and hot gas in the Local Group and the intergalactic medium. We follow the dynamics, chemical evolution, heat flow and gas flows of a hierarchy of scales, including: protogalactic clouds, galactic halos, and the Local Group itself. Within this hierarchy, the Galaxy is built via mergers of protogalactic fragments. We find t…
▽ More
We present a schematic model for the formation of baryonic galactic halos and hot gas in the Local Group and the intergalactic medium. We follow the dynamics, chemical evolution, heat flow and gas flows of a hierarchy of scales, including: protogalactic clouds, galactic halos, and the Local Group itself. Within this hierarchy, the Galaxy is built via mergers of protogalactic fragments. We find that early bursts of star formation lead to a large population of remnants (mostly white dwarfs), which would reside presently in the halo and contribute to the dark component observed in the microlensing experiments. The hot, metal-rich gas from early starbursts and merging evaporates from the clouds and is eventually incorporated into the intergalactic medium. The model thus suggests that most microlensing objects could be white dwarfs ($m \sim 0.5 \msol$), which comprise a significant fraction of the halo mass. Furthermore, the Local Group could have a component of metal-rich hot gas similar to, although less than, that observed in larger clusters. We discuss the known constraints on such a scenario and show that all local observations can be satisfied with present data in this model. The best-fit model has a halo that is 40% baryonic, with an upper limit of 77%.
△ Less
Submitted 7 October, 1996; v1 submitted 17 April, 1996;
originally announced April 1996.
-
Cosmological Implications of the First Measurement of the Local ISM Abundance of $^3$He
Authors:
Michael S. Turner,
James W. Truran,
David N. Schramm,
Craig J. Copi
Abstract:
Deuterium plays a crucial role in testing big-bang nucleosynthesis. Its chemical evolution, while simple (it is burned to $^3$He), is intertwined with the more complicated evolution of $^3$He. Gloeckler \& Geiss' new measurement of the $^3$He abundance and the HST measurement of D, both in the local ISM today, can be compared to the pre-solar nebula abundances of D and $^3$He. Within the uncerta…
▽ More
Deuterium plays a crucial role in testing big-bang nucleosynthesis. Its chemical evolution, while simple (it is burned to $^3$He), is intertwined with the more complicated evolution of $^3$He. Gloeckler \& Geiss' new measurement of the $^3$He abundance and the HST measurement of D, both in the local ISM today, can be compared to the pre-solar nebula abundances of D and $^3$He. Within the uncertainties, the sum of D + $^3$He relative to hydrogen is unchanged. This provides some validation of the cosmological utility of D + $^3$He, first suggested by Yang et al (1984), and further, indicates that over the past 4.5 Gyr there has been at most modest stellar production of $^3$He, in contradiction with stellar modeling, or modest stellar destruction of $^3$He, in contradiction with some ``solar spoons.'' While the earlier Galactic evolution of D + $^3$He cannot be constrained directly, it is expected to be dominated by massive stars, which deplete their $^3$He and produce metals. Based on the Galactic metallicity and the constancy of D + $^3$He over the past 4.5 Gyr, we derive a more empirically based lower bound to the cosmological baryon density; while not dramatically different from the original bound of Yang et al (1984) based on D + $^3$He, it alleviates some of the cosmic tension between the big-bang $^4$He abundance and those of D and $^3$He.
△ Less
Submitted 9 February, 1996;
originally announced February 1996.
-
Concordance of X-Ray Cluster Data With BBN In Mixed Dark Matter Models
Authors:
Russell W. Strickland,
David N. Schramm
Abstract:
If the hot, X-ray emitting gas in rich clusters forms a fair sample of the universe (as in Cold Dark Matter (CDM) models), and the universe is at the critical density, $Ω_T = 1$, then the data appears to imply a baryon fraction, $Ω_{b,x}$ ($Ω_{b,x}\equiv Ω_b$ derived from X-ray cluster data), larger than that predicted by Big Bang Nucleosynthesis (BBN). While various other systematic effects suc…
▽ More
If the hot, X-ray emitting gas in rich clusters forms a fair sample of the universe (as in Cold Dark Matter (CDM) models), and the universe is at the critical density, $Ω_T = 1$, then the data appears to imply a baryon fraction, $Ω_{b,x}$ ($Ω_{b,x}\equiv Ω_b$ derived from X-ray cluster data), larger than that predicted by Big Bang Nucleosynthesis (BBN). While various other systematic effects such as clumping can lower $Ω_{b,x}$, in this paper we use an elementary analysis to show that a simple admixture of Hot Dark Matter (HDM, low mass neutrinos) with CDM to yield mixed dark matter shifts $Ω_{b,x}$ down so that significant overlap with $Ω_b$ from BBN can occur for $H_0 \lsim 75\;{\rm km/sec/Mpc}$, even without invoking the possible aforementioned effects. The overlap interval is slightly larger for lower mass neutrinos since fewer cluster on the scale of the hot X-ray gas. We illustrate this result quantitatively in terms of a simple isothermal model. More realistic velocity dispersion profiles, with less centrally-peaked density profiles, imply that fewer neutrinos are trapped and, thus, further increase the interval of overlap. However, we also note that if future observations of light element abundances find that $Ω_b h^2 \lsim 0.018$, the range of concordance in this simple mixed dark matter model vanishes.
△ Less
Submitted 24 November, 1995;
originally announced November 1995.
-
The Local Abundance of $^3$He: A Confrontation Between Theory and Observation
Authors:
Sean T. Scully,
Michel Casse,
Keith A. Olive,
D. N. Schramm,
J. Truran,
E. Vangioni-Flam
Abstract:
Determinations of the \he3 concentrations in Galactic matter serve to impose interesting and important constraints both on cosmological models and on models of Galactic chemical evolution. At present, observations of \he3 in the solar system and in the interstellar medium today suggest that the \he3 abundance has not increased significantly over the history of the Galaxy, while theoretical model…
▽ More
Determinations of the \he3 concentrations in Galactic matter serve to impose interesting and important constraints both on cosmological models and on models of Galactic chemical evolution. At present, observations of \he3 in the solar system and in the interstellar medium today suggest that the \he3 abundance has not increased significantly over the history of the Galaxy, while theoretical models of Galactic chemical evolution (utilizing current nucleosynthesis yields from stellar evolution and supernova models) predict a rather substantial increase in \he3. We consider the possibility that the solar \he3 abundance may have been affected by stellar processing in the solar neighborhood prior to the formation of the solar system. Such a discrepancy between solar abundances and average galactic abundances by as much as a factor of two, may be evidenced by several isotopic anomalies. Local destruction of \he3 by a similar amount could serve to help to reconcile the expected increase in the \he3 abundance predicted by models of galactic chemical evolution. We find however, that the production of heavier elements, such as oxygen, places a strong constraint on the degree of \he3 destruction. We also explore the implications of both alternative models of Galactic chemical evolution and the stellar yields for \he3 in low mass stars, which can explain the history of the \he3 concentration in the Galaxy.
△ Less
Submitted 18 August, 1995;
originally announced August 1995.
-
Assessing Big-Bang Nucleosynthesis
Authors:
Craig J. Copi,
David N. Schramm,
Michael S. Turner
Abstract:
Systematic uncertainties in the light-element abundances and their evolution make a rigorous statistical assessment difficult. However, using Bayesian methods we show that the following statement is robust: the predicted and measured abundances are consistent with 95\% credibility only if the baryon-to-photon ratio is between $2\times 10^{-10}$ and $6.5\times 10^{-10}$ and the number of light ne…
▽ More
Systematic uncertainties in the light-element abundances and their evolution make a rigorous statistical assessment difficult. However, using Bayesian methods we show that the following statement is robust: the predicted and measured abundances are consistent with 95\% credibility only if the baryon-to-photon ratio is between $2\times 10^{-10}$ and $6.5\times 10^{-10}$ and the number of light neutrino species is less than 3.9. Our analysis suggests that the $^4$He abundance may have been systematically underestimated.
△ Less
Submitted 7 August, 1995;
originally announced August 1995.
-
A Break in the Highest Energy Cosmic Ray Spectrum: A Signature of New Physics?
Authors:
G. Sigl,
S. Lee,
D. N. Schramm,
P. Bhattacharjee
Abstract:
Recent experimental data from the Fly's Eye and the Akeno array seem to indicate significant structure in the ultrahigh energy cosmic ray spectrum above $10^{18}\eV$. A statistically significant dip has been established at about $5\times10^{18}\eV$. In addition, each experiment observed a different superhigh energy event above $10^{20}\eV$ separated from the rest of the data by about half a deca…
▽ More
Recent experimental data from the Fly's Eye and the Akeno array seem to indicate significant structure in the ultrahigh energy cosmic ray spectrum above $10^{18}\eV$. A statistically significant dip has been established at about $5\times10^{18}\eV$. In addition, each experiment observed a different superhigh energy event above $10^{20}\eV$ separated from the rest of the data by about half a decade in energy. In this article we discuss what this implies for the existence or non-existence of the ``Greisen-Zatsepin-Kuz'min cutoff'', a long lasting and still open question in cosmic ray physics. This cutoff, caused by energy losses in the cosmic microwave background, is predicted to occur at a few times $10^{19}\eV$ if cosmic rays are produced by shock acceleration of lower energy particles at extragalactic distances. We show that from the spectral point of view, sources nearer than a few $\Mpc$ are still consistent with the data at the $1σ$ level, provided these sources accelerate particles beyond $3\times10^{20}\eV$. However, persistence of the apparent gap in the existing data at the level of a 4 times higher total exposure would rule out a wide range of acceleration models at $98\%$ C.L., whether they rely on nearby or extragalactic sources. This might hint to the existence of a ``top down'' mechanism which produces an additional hard component of ultrahigh energy particles directly, say, by decay from some higher energy scale in contrast to bottom up acceleration of charged particles. In this scenario a cutoff followed by a pronounced spectral flattening and possibly even a gap could naturally be formed.
△ Less
Submitted 22 June, 1995;
originally announced June 1995.
-
Big-Bang Nucleosynthesis and Galactic Chemical Evolution
Authors:
Craig J. Copi,
David N. Schramm,
Michael S. Turner
Abstract:
Deuterium is the best indicator of the baryon density; however, only its present abundance is known (and only locally) and its chemical evolution is intertwined with that of $^3$He. Because galactic abundances are spatially heterogeneous, mean chemical-evolution models are not well suited for extrapolating the pre-solar D and $^3$He abundances to their primeval values. We introduce a new approac…
▽ More
Deuterium is the best indicator of the baryon density; however, only its present abundance is known (and only locally) and its chemical evolution is intertwined with that of $^3$He. Because galactic abundances are spatially heterogeneous, mean chemical-evolution models are not well suited for extrapolating the pre-solar D and $^3$He abundances to their primeval values. We introduce a new approach which explicitly addresses heterogeneity, and show that the decade-old big-bang nucleosynthesis concordance interval $η\approx (2 -8)\times 10^{-10}$ based on D and $^3$He is robust.
△ Less
Submitted 18 August, 1995; v1 submitted 16 June, 1995;
originally announced June 1995.
-
The Nuclear Impact on Cosmology: The $H_0\hbox{-}Ω$ Diagram
Authors:
Craig J. Copi,
David N. Schramm
Abstract:
The \HOmega\ diagram is resurrected to dramatically illustrate the nature of the key problems in physical cosmology today and the role that nuclear physics plays in many of them. In particular it is noted that the constraints on \OmegaB\ from big bang nucleosynthesis do not overlap with the constraints on \OmegaVis\ nor have significant overlap with the lower bound on $Ω$ from cluster studies. T…
▽ More
The \HOmega\ diagram is resurrected to dramatically illustrate the nature of the key problems in physical cosmology today and the role that nuclear physics plays in many of them. In particular it is noted that the constraints on \OmegaB\ from big bang nucleosynthesis do not overlap with the constraints on \OmegaVis\ nor have significant overlap with the lower bound on $Ω$ from cluster studies. The former implies that the bulk of the baryons are dark and the later is the principle argument for non-baryonic dark matter. A comparison with hot x-ray emitting gas in clusters is also made. The lower bound on the age of the universe from globular cluster ages (hydrogen burning in low mass stars) and from nucleocosmochronology also illustrates the Hubble constant requirement $H_0 \le 66 \Hunits$ for $Ω_0 = 1$\@. It is also noted that high values of $H_0$ ($\sim 80\Hunits$) even more strongly require the presence of non-baryonic dark matter. The lower limit on $H_0$ ($\ge 38\Hunits$) from carbon detonation driven type~Ia supernova constrains long ages and only marginally allows \OmegaB\ to overlap with \OmegaClus. Diagrams of \HOmega\ for $Λ_0=0$ and $Λ_0\neq 0$ are presented to show that the need for non-baryonic dark matter is independent of $Λ$.
△ Less
Submitted 7 April, 1995;
originally announced April 1995.
-
HELIUM PHOTODISINTEGRATION AND NUCLEOSYNTHESIS: IMPLICATIONS FOR TOPOLOGICAL DEFECTS, HIGH ENERGY COSMIC RAYS, AND MASSIVE BLACK HOLES
Authors:
G. Sigl,
K. Jedamzik,
D. N. Schramm,
V. S. Berezinsky
Abstract:
We consider the production of $^3$He and $^2$H by $^4$He photodisintegration initiated by non-thermal energy releases during early cosmic epochs. We find that this process cannot be the predominant source of primordial $^2$H since it would result in anomalously high $^3$He/D ratios in conflict with standard chemical evolution assumptions. We apply this fact to constrain topological defect models…
▽ More
We consider the production of $^3$He and $^2$H by $^4$He photodisintegration initiated by non-thermal energy releases during early cosmic epochs. We find that this process cannot be the predominant source of primordial $^2$H since it would result in anomalously high $^3$He/D ratios in conflict with standard chemical evolution assumptions. We apply this fact to constrain topological defect models of highest energy cosmic ray (HECR) production. Such models have been proposed as possible sources of ultrahigh energy particles and gamma-rays with energies above $10^{20}$eV. The constraints on these models derived from $^4$He-photodisintegration are compared to corresponding limits from spectral distortions of the cosmic microwave background radiation (CMBR) and from the observed diffuse gamma-ray background. It is shown that for reasonable primary particle injection spectra superconducting cosmic strings, unlike ordinary strings or annihilating monopoles, cannot produce the HECR flux at the present epoch without violating at least the $^4$He-photodisintegration bound. The constraint from the diffuse gamma-ray background rules out the dominant production of HECR by the decay of Grand Unification particles in models with cosmological evolution assuming standard fragmentation functions. Constraints on massive black hole induced photodisintegration are also discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 26 March, 1995;
originally announced March 1995.
-
What's The Problem With ^3He?
Authors:
Keith A. Olive,
Robert T. Rood,
David N. Schramm,
James Truran,
Elisabeth Vangioni-Flam
Abstract:
We consider the galactic evolutionary history of \he3 in models which deplete deuterium by as much as a factor of 2 to $\sim$ 15 from its primordial value to its present day observed value in the ISM. We show that when \he3 production in low mass stars (1 -- 3 $M_\odot$) is included over the history of the galaxy, \he3 is greatly over-produced and exceeds the inferred solar values and the abunda…
▽ More
We consider the galactic evolutionary history of \he3 in models which deplete deuterium by as much as a factor of 2 to $\sim$ 15 from its primordial value to its present day observed value in the ISM. We show that when \he3 production in low mass stars (1 -- 3 $M_\odot$) is included over the history of the galaxy, \he3 is greatly over-produced and exceeds the inferred solar values and the abundances determined in galactic \hii regions. Furthermore, the ISM abundances show a disturbing dispersion which is difficult to understand from the point of view of standard chemical evolution models. In principle, resolution of the problem may lie in either 1) the calculated \he3 production in low mass stars; 2) the observations of the \he3 abundance; or 3) an observational bias towards regions of depleted \he3. Since \he3 observations in planetary nebula support the calculated \he3 production in low mass stars, option (1) is unlikely. We will argue for option (3) since the \he3 interstellar observations are indeed made in regions dominated by massive stars in which \he3 is destroyed. In conclusion, we note that the problem with \he3 seems to be galactic and not cosmological.
△ Less
Submitted 19 October, 1994;
originally announced October 1994.
-
Large Scale Baryon Isocurvature Inhomogeneities
Authors:
Craig J. Copi,
Keith A. Olive,
David N. Schramm
Abstract:
Big bang nucleosynthesis constraints on baryon isocurvature perturbations are determined. A simple model ignoring the effects of the scale of the perturbations is first reviewed. This model is then extended to test the claim that large amplitude perturbations will collapse, forming compact objects and preventing their baryons from contributing to the observed baryon density. It is found that bar…
▽ More
Big bang nucleosynthesis constraints on baryon isocurvature perturbations are determined. A simple model ignoring the effects of the scale of the perturbations is first reviewed. This model is then extended to test the claim that large amplitude perturbations will collapse, forming compact objects and preventing their baryons from contributing to the observed baryon density. It is found that baryon isocurvature perturbations are constrained to provide only a slight increase in the density of baryons in the universe over the standard homogeneous model. In particular it is found that models which rely on power laws and the random phase approximation for the power spectrum are incompatible with big bang nucleosynthesis unless an {\em ad hoc}, small scale cutoff is included.
△ Less
Submitted 3 October, 1994;
originally announced October 1994.
-
A Merger Model and Globular Cluster Formation
Authors:
Sangjin Lee,
David N. Schramm,
Grant J. Mathews
Abstract:
We propose a self-consistent model for globular cluster formation in, but not limited to, our Galaxy, based on the merger model of Mathews and Schramm (1993). Stars and star clusters form in bursts at the merging interfaces as protogalactic clouds collide. We describe the formation of those star clusters with a simple schematic ansatz which takes into account the thermal and Kelvin-Helmholtz ins…
▽ More
We propose a self-consistent model for globular cluster formation in, but not limited to, our Galaxy, based on the merger model of Mathews and Schramm (1993). Stars and star clusters form in bursts at the merging interfaces as protogalactic clouds collide. We describe the formation of those star clusters with a simple schematic ansatz which takes into account the thermal and Kelvin-Helmholtz instabilities. It is shown that this model is consistent with many observational properties such as the age and metallicity distributions of globular clusters, the overall number of globular clusters, and the near constancy of the number of globular clusters in different size host galaxies. Most of the features of this merger model are insensitive to choices of parameters. However, the model does not exhibit two distinct populations of globular clusters, i.e. halo clusters and disk clusters. Possible explanations for this are presented.
△ Less
Submitted 17 August, 1994;
originally announced August 1994.
-
Big-Bang Nucleosynthesis and the Baryon Density of the Universe
Authors:
Craig J Copi,
David N. Schramm,
Michael S. Turner
Abstract:
Big-bang nucleosynthesis is one of the cornerstones of the standard cosmology. For almost thirty years its predictions have been used to test the big-bang model to within a fraction of a second of the bang. The concordance that exists between the predicted and observed abundances of D, $^3$He, $^4$He and $^7$Li provides important confirmation of the standard cosmology and leads to the most accur…
▽ More
Big-bang nucleosynthesis is one of the cornerstones of the standard cosmology. For almost thirty years its predictions have been used to test the big-bang model to within a fraction of a second of the bang. The concordance that exists between the predicted and observed abundances of D, $^3$He, $^4$He and $^7$Li provides important confirmation of the standard cosmology and leads to the most accurate determination of the baryon density, between $1.7 \times 10^{-31}\gcmm3$ and $4.1\times 10^{-31}\gcmm3$ (corresponding to between about 1\% and 14\% of critical density). This measurement of the density of ordinary matter is crucial to almost every aspect of cosmology and is pivotal to the establishment of two dark-matter problems: (i) most of the baryons are dark, and (ii) if the total mass density is greater than about 14\% of the critical density as many determinations now indicate, the bulk of the dark matter must be ``nonbaryonic,'' comprised of elementary particles left from the earliest moments. We critically review the present status of primordial nucleosynthesis and discuss future prospects.
△ Less
Submitted 7 July, 1994; v1 submitted 1 July, 1994;
originally announced July 1994.
-
On Solar Model Solutions to the Solar Neutrino Problem
Authors:
X. Shi,
D. N. Schramm,
D. S. P. Dearborn
Abstract:
Without assuming any solar models and neutrino flavor conversions, $^8$B neutrinos seen by the Kamiokande experiment should contribute 2.6$\pm 0.45$ SNU to the chlorine experiment. When this rate is compared with the total event rate of 2.3$\pm 0.2$ SNU observed by the Homestake experiment which should inlude a 0.2 SNU contribution from uncertainty-free pep neutrinos, there may still be a possib…
▽ More
Without assuming any solar models and neutrino flavor conversions, $^8$B neutrinos seen by the Kamiokande experiment should contribute 2.6$\pm 0.45$ SNU to the chlorine experiment. When this rate is compared with the total event rate of 2.3$\pm 0.2$ SNU observed by the Homestake experiment which should inlude a 0.2 SNU contribution from uncertainty-free pep neutrinos, there may still be a possible evidence that $^7$Be neutrinos are more severely suppressed than the $^8$B neutrinos with respect to the predictions of standard solar models, which cannot be explained by any known astrophysics solution. Given a Kamiokande event rate of larger than 36$\%$ (2$σ$) of the prediciton of Bahcall and Pinsonneault's standard solar model, variations of standard solar models yield minimal rates of 3.6 SNU for the Homestake experiment and 114 SNU for GALLEX and SAGE. Therefore, variations of standard solar models as solutions to the solar neutrino problem are so far inconsistent with the Homestake experiment and only marginally allowed by the gallium experiments. If the gallium experiments confirm a flux significantly below 114 SNU, it would imply unconventional physics.
△ Less
Submitted 25 April, 1994; v1 submitted 6 April, 1994;
originally announced April 1994.
-
Possible Systematic Decreases in the Age of Globular Clusters
Authors:
X. Shi,
D. N. Schramm,
D. S. P. Dearborn,
J. W. Truran
Abstract:
The ages of globular clusters inferred from observations depends sensitively on assumptions like the initial helium abundance and the mass loss rate. A high helium abundance (e.g., $Y\approx$0.28) or a mass loss rate of $\sim$10$^{-11}M_\odot$ yr$^{-1}$ near the main sequence turn-off region lowers the current age estimate from 14 Gyr to about 10--12 Gyr, significantly relaxing the constraints o…
▽ More
The ages of globular clusters inferred from observations depends sensitively on assumptions like the initial helium abundance and the mass loss rate. A high helium abundance (e.g., $Y\approx$0.28) or a mass loss rate of $\sim$10$^{-11}M_\odot$ yr$^{-1}$ near the main sequence turn-off region lowers the current age estimate from 14 Gyr to about 10--12 Gyr, significantly relaxing the constraints on the Hubble constant, allowing values as high as 60km/sec/Mpc for a universe with the critical density and 90km/sec/Mpc for a baryon-only universe. Possible mechanisms for the helium enhancement in globular clusters are discussed, as are arguments for an instability strip induced mass loss near the turn-off. Ages lower than 10 Gyr are not possible even with the operation of both of these mechanisms unless the initial helium abundance in globular clusters is $>0.30$, which would conflict with indirect measurements of helium abundances in globular clusters.
△ Less
Submitted 29 March, 1994;
originally announced March 1994.
-
On the Origin of Highest Energy Cosmic Rays
Authors:
G. Sigl,
D. N. Schramm,
P. Bhattacharjee
Abstract:
In this paper we show that the conventional diffusive shock acceleration mechanism for cosmic rays associated with relativistic astrophysical shocks in active galactic nuclei (AGNs) has severe difficulties to explain the highest energy cosmic ray events. We show that protons above around $2\times10^{20}\eV$ could have marginally been produced by this mechanism in an AGN or a rich galaxy cluster…
▽ More
In this paper we show that the conventional diffusive shock acceleration mechanism for cosmic rays associated with relativistic astrophysical shocks in active galactic nuclei (AGNs) has severe difficulties to explain the highest energy cosmic ray events. We show that protons above around $2\times10^{20}\eV$ could have marginally been produced by this mechanism in an AGN or a rich galaxy cluster not further away than around $100\Mpc$. However, for the highest energy Fly's Eye and Yakutsk events this is inconsistent with the observed arrival directions. Galactic and intergalactic magnetic fields appear unable to alter the direction of such energetic particles by more than a few degrees. We also discuss some other options for these events associated with relativistic particles including pulsar acceleration of high $Z$ nuclei. At the present stage of knowledge the concept of topological defects left over from the early universe as the source for such events appears to be a promising option. Such sources are discussed and possible tests of this hypothesis are proposed.
△ Less
Submitted 17 March, 1994;
originally announced March 1994.
-
Constraints on the Strength of a Primordial Magnetic Field from Big Bang Nucleosynthesis
Authors:
Baolian Cheng,
David N. Schramm,
James W. Truran
Abstract:
The effects of magnetic fields on Big Bang Nucleosynthesis(BBN) have been calculated, and the impact on the abundances of the light elements have been investigated numerically. An upper limit on the strength of primordial magnetic fields compatible with observations of light element abundances has been thus obtained. In the framework of standard BBN theory, the maximum strength of the primordial…
▽ More
The effects of magnetic fields on Big Bang Nucleosynthesis(BBN) have been calculated, and the impact on the abundances of the light elements have been investigated numerically. An upper limit on the strength of primordial magnetic fields compatible with observations of light element abundances has been thus obtained. In the framework of standard BBN theory, the maximum strength of the primordial magnetic fields, on scales greater than $10^4$cm but smaller than the event horizon at the BBN epoch ($\sim 1$ min., $\sim 2\times 10^{12}$cm), is $\le 10^{11}$ Gauss. This limit is shown to allow magnetic fields at the time of recombination no stronger than $\sim 0.1$ gauss on scales $\ge 10^{11}{\rm cm}$. Our results also strongly indicate that, at the BBN epoch, and for field strengths $B\le10^{13}$gauss, the effects of magnetic fields on the primordial abundances of light elements are dominated by effects from reaction rates in the presense of primeval magnetic fields rather than by magnetic density effects on the expansion rate.
△ Less
Submitted 27 August, 1993;
originally announced August 1993.
-
Interaction Rates at High Magnetic Field Strengths and High Degeneracy
Authors:
Baolian Cheng,
David N. Schramm,
James W. Truran
Abstract:
In this paper, we have derived the the effects of strong magnetic fields ${\bf \vec B}$ on nucleon and particle reaction rates of astrophysical significance. We have explored the sensitivity to the presence of arbitrary degeneracy and polarization. The possible astrophysical applications of our results are discussed.
In this paper, we have derived the the effects of strong magnetic fields ${\bf \vec B}$ on nucleon and particle reaction rates of astrophysical significance. We have explored the sensitivity to the presence of arbitrary degeneracy and polarization. The possible astrophysical applications of our results are discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 26 August, 1993;
originally announced August 1993.
-
Production of Li, Be \& B from Baryon Inhomogeneous Primordial Nucleosynthesis
Authors:
David Thomas,
David N. Schramm,
Keith A. Olive,
Grant J. Mathews,
Bradley S. Meyer,
Brian D. Fields
Abstract:
We investigate the possibility that inhomogeneous nucleosynthesis may eventually be used to explain the abundances of \li6, \be9 and B in population II stars. The present work differs from previous studies in that we have used a more extensive reaction network. It is demonstrated that in the simplest scenario the abundances of the light elements with $A\le7$ constrain the separation of inhomogen…
▽ More
We investigate the possibility that inhomogeneous nucleosynthesis may eventually be used to explain the abundances of \li6, \be9 and B in population II stars. The present work differs from previous studies in that we have used a more extensive reaction network. It is demonstrated that in the simplest scenario the abundances of the light elements with $A\le7$ constrain the separation of inhomogeneities to sufficiently small scales that the model is indistinguishable from homogeneous nucleosynthesis and that the abundances of \li6, \be9\ and B are then below observations by several orders of magnitude. This conclusion does not depend on the \li7 constraint. We also examine alternative scenarios which involve a post-nucleosynthesis reprocessing of the light elements to reproduce the observed abundances of Li and B, while allowing for a somewhat higher baryon density (still well below the cosmological critical density). Future B/H measurements may be able to exclude even this exotic scenario and further restrict primordial nucleosynthesis to approach the homogeneous model conclusions.
△ Less
Submitted 20 August, 1993;
originally announced August 1993.
-
Constraints on Neutrino Oscillations from Big Bang Nucleosynethesis
Authors:
X. Shi,
D. N. Schramm,
B. D. Fields
Abstract:
We discuss in detail the effect of neutrino oscillations in Big Bang nucleosynthesis, between active and sterile neutrinos, as well as between active and active neutrinos. We calculate the constraints on mixings between active and sterile neutrinos from the present observation of the primordial helium abundance and discuss the potential implications on various astrophysical and cosmological prob…
▽ More
We discuss in detail the effect of neutrino oscillations in Big Bang nucleosynthesis, between active and sterile neutrinos, as well as between active and active neutrinos. We calculate the constraints on mixings between active and sterile neutrinos from the present observation of the primordial helium abundance and discuss the potential implications on various astrophysical and cosmological problems of such oscillations. In particular, we show that large angle sterile neutrino mixing seems to be excluded as a MSW solution to the solar neutrino situation or a solution to the atmospheric neutrino mixing hinted at in some underground experiments. We show how with this constraint, the next generation of solar neutrino experiments should be able to determine the resolution of the solar neutrino problem. It is also shown how sterile neutrinos remain a viable dark matter candidate.
△ Less
Submitted 16 July, 1993;
originally announced July 1993.
-
Testing for Gaussianity Through the Three Point Temperature Correlation Function
Authors:
Xiaochun Luo,
D. N. Schramm
Abstract:
One of the crucial aspects of density perturbations that are produced by the standard inflation scenario is that they are Gaussian where seeds produced by topological defects tend to be non-Gaussian. The three point correlation function of the temperature anisotropy of the cosmic microwave background radiation (CBR) provides a sensitive test of this aspect of the primordial density field. In thi…
▽ More
One of the crucial aspects of density perturbations that are produced by the standard inflation scenario is that they are Gaussian where seeds produced by topological defects tend to be non-Gaussian. The three point correlation function of the temperature anisotropy of the cosmic microwave background radiation (CBR) provides a sensitive test of this aspect of the primordial density field. In this paper, this function is calculated in the general context of various allowed non-Gaussian models. It is shown that by COBE and the forthcoming South Pole and Balloon CBR anisotropy data may be able to test provide a crucial test of Gaussianity.
△ Less
Submitted 8 May, 1993;
originally announced May 1993.
-
Constraints on Dirac Neutrinos from SN 1987A
Authors:
R. Mayle,
D. N. Schramm,
M. S. Turner,
J. Wilson
Abstract:
The Livermore Supernova Explosion Code was used to calculate the effect of a massive Dirac neutrino on neutrino emission from SN 1987A in a fully self-consistent manner. Spin-flip interactions lead to the copious emission of sterile, right-handed neutrinos and cool the core faster than the observed neutrino emission time for Dirac masses exceeding about 3$\,$keV. This limit is relaxed to $7\,$ke…
▽ More
The Livermore Supernova Explosion Code was used to calculate the effect of a massive Dirac neutrino on neutrino emission from SN 1987A in a fully self-consistent manner. Spin-flip interactions lead to the copious emission of sterile, right-handed neutrinos and cool the core faster than the observed neutrino emission time for Dirac masses exceeding about 3$\,$keV. This limit is relaxed to $7\,$keV if pion emission processes in the core are neglected. These limits are compared with the previous less stringent limits of Burrows et al.
△ Less
Submitted 13 January, 1993;
originally announced January 1993.
-
Primordial Nucleosynthesis and the Abundances of Beryllium and Boron
Authors:
David Thomas,
David N. Schramm,
Keith A. Olive,
Brian D. Fields
Abstract:
The ability to now make measurements of Be and B as well as put constraints on \lisix\ abundances in metal-poor stars has led to a detailed reexamination of Big Bang Nucleosynthesis in the $A\groughly6$ regime. The nuclear reaction network has been significantly expanded with many new rates added. It is demonstrated that although a number of $A>7$ reaction rates are poorly determined, even with…
▽ More
The ability to now make measurements of Be and B as well as put constraints on \lisix\ abundances in metal-poor stars has led to a detailed reexamination of Big Bang Nucleosynthesis in the $A\groughly6$ regime. The nuclear reaction network has been significantly expanded with many new rates added. It is demonstrated that although a number of $A>7$ reaction rates are poorly determined, even with extreme values chosen, the standard homogeneous model is unable to produce significant yields (Be/H and B/H $<10^{-17}$ when $A\le7$ abundances fit) above $A=7$ and the \liseven/\lisix\ ratio always exceeds 500. We also preliminarily explore inhomogeneous models, such as those inspired by a first order quark-hadron phase transition, where regions with high neutron/proton ratios can allow some leakage up to $A>7$. However models that fit the $A\le7$ abundances still seem to have difficulty in obtaining significant $A>7$ yields.
△ Less
Submitted 18 June, 1992;
originally announced June 1992.
