-
Tidal evolution of cored and cuspy dark matter halos
Authors:
Xiaolong Du,
Andrew Benson,
Zhichao Carton Zeng,
Tommaso Treu,
Annika H. G. Peter,
Charlie Mace,
Fangzhou Jiang,
Shengqi Yang,
Charles Gannon,
Daniel Gilman,
Anna. M. Nierenberg,
Ethan O. Nadler
Abstract:
The internal structure and abundance of dark matter halos and subhalos are powerful probes of the nature of dark matter. In order to compare observations with dark matter models, accurate theoretical predictions of these quantities are needed. We present a fast and accurate method to describe the tidal evolution of subhalos within their parent halo, based on a semi-analytic approach. We first cons…
▽ More
The internal structure and abundance of dark matter halos and subhalos are powerful probes of the nature of dark matter. In order to compare observations with dark matter models, accurate theoretical predictions of these quantities are needed. We present a fast and accurate method to describe the tidal evolution of subhalos within their parent halo, based on a semi-analytic approach. We first consider idealized N-body simulations of subhalos within their host halo, using a generalized mass density profile that describes their properties in a variety of dark matter models at infall, including popular warm, cold, and self-interacting ones. Using these simulations we construct tidal "tracks" for the evolution of subhalos based on their conditions at infall. Second, we use the results of these simulations to build semi-analytic models for tidal effects, including stripping and heating and implement them within the code GALACTICUS. Our semi-analytic models can accurately predict the tidal evolution of both cored and cuspy subhalos, including the bound mass and density profiles, providing a powerful and efficient tool for studying the post-infall properties of subhalos in different dark matter models.
△ Less
Submitted 15 July, 2024; v1 submitted 14 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
Convergence Tests of Self-Interacting Dark Matter Simulations
Authors:
Charlie Mace,
Zhichao Carton Zeng,
Annika H. G. Peter,
Xiaolong Du,
Shengqi Yang,
Andrew Benson,
Mark Vogelsberger
Abstract:
Self-interacting dark matter (SIDM) theory predicts that dark matter halos experience core-collapse, a process where the halo's inner region rapidly increases in density and decreases in size. The N-body simulations used to study this process can suffer from numerical errors when simulation parameters are selected incorrectly. Optimal choices for simulation parameters are well studied for cold dar…
▽ More
Self-interacting dark matter (SIDM) theory predicts that dark matter halos experience core-collapse, a process where the halo's inner region rapidly increases in density and decreases in size. The N-body simulations used to study this process can suffer from numerical errors when simulation parameters are selected incorrectly. Optimal choices for simulation parameters are well studied for cold dark matter (CDM), but are not deeply understood when self-interactions are included. In order to perform reliable N-body simulations and model core-collapse accurately we must understand the potential numerical errors, how to diagnose them, and what parameter selections must be made to reduce them. We use the \texttt{Arepo} N-body code to perform convergence tests of core-collapsing SIDM halos across a range of halo concentrations and SIDM cross-sections, and quantify potential numerical issues related to mass resolution, timestep size, and gravitational softening length. Our tests discover that halos with fewer than $10^5$ simulation particles, a resolution typically not met by subhalos in N-body simulations, suffer from significant discreteness noise that leads to variation and extreme outliers in the collapse rate. At our lowest resolution of $N=10^4$ particles, this collapse time variation can reach as high as 20\%. At this low resolution we also find a bias in collapse times and a small number of extreme outliers. Additionally, we find that simulations which run far beyond the age of the Universe, which have been used to calibrate SIDM gravothermal fluid models in previous work, have a sensitivity to the timestep size that is not present in shorter simulations or simulations using only CDM. Our work shows that choices of simulation parameters that yield converged results for some halo masses and SIDM models do not necessarily yield convergence for others.
△ Less
Submitted 12 April, 2024; v1 submitted 2 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Till the core collapses: the evolution and properties of self-interacting dark matter subhalos
Authors:
Zhichao Carton Zeng,
Annika H. G. Peter,
Xiaolong Du,
Shengqi Yang,
Andrew Benson,
Francis-Yan Cyr-Racine,
Fangzhou Jiang,
Charlie Mace,
R. Benton Metcalf
Abstract:
One of the hottest questions in the cosmology of self-interacting dark matter (SIDM) is whether scatterings can induce detectable core-collapse in halos by the present day. Because gravitational tides can accelerate core-collapse, the most promising targets to observe core-collapse are satellite galaxies and subhalo systems. However, simulating small subhalos is computationally intensive, especial…
▽ More
One of the hottest questions in the cosmology of self-interacting dark matter (SIDM) is whether scatterings can induce detectable core-collapse in halos by the present day. Because gravitational tides can accelerate core-collapse, the most promising targets to observe core-collapse are satellite galaxies and subhalo systems. However, simulating small subhalos is computationally intensive, especially when subhalos start to core-collapse. In this work, we present a hierarchical framework for simulating a population of SIDM subhalos, which reduces the computation time to linear order in the total number of subhalos. With this method, we simulate substructure lensing systems with multiple velocity-dependent SIDM models, and show how subhalo evolution depends on the SIDM model, subhalo mass and orbits. We find that an SIDM cross section of $\gtrsim 200$ cm$^2$/g at velocity scales relevant for subhalos' internal heat transfer is needed for a significant fraction of subhalos to core-collapse in a typical lens system at redshift $z=0.5$, and that core-collapse has unique observable features in lensing. We show quantitatively that core-collapse in subhalos is typically accelerated compared to field halos, except when the SIDM cross section is non-negligible ($\gtrsim \mathcal{O}(1)$ cm$^2$/g) at subhalos' orbital velocities, in which case evaporation by the host can delay core-collapse. This suggests that substructure lensing can be used to probe velocity-dependent SIDM models, especially if line-of-sight structures (field halos) can be distinguished from lens-plane subhalos. Intriguingly, we find that core-collapse in subhalos can explain the recently reported ultra-steep density profiles of substructures found by lensing with the \emph{Hubble Space Telescope}
△ Less
Submitted 4 November, 2023; v1 submitted 15 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
A quantitative comparison between velocity dependent SIDM cross sections constrained by the gravothermal and isothermal models
Authors:
Shengqi Yang,
Fangzhou Jiang,
Andrew Benson,
Yi-Ming Zhong,
Charlie Mace,
Xiaolong Du,
Zhichao Carton Zeng,
Annika H. G. Peter,
Moritz S. Fischer
Abstract:
One necessary step for probing the nature of self-interacting dark matter (SIDM) particles with astrophysical observations is to pin down any possible velocity dependence in the SIDM cross section. Major challenges for achieving this goal include eliminating, or mitigating, the impact of the baryonic components and tidal effects within the dark matter halos of interest -- the effects of these proc…
▽ More
One necessary step for probing the nature of self-interacting dark matter (SIDM) particles with astrophysical observations is to pin down any possible velocity dependence in the SIDM cross section. Major challenges for achieving this goal include eliminating, or mitigating, the impact of the baryonic components and tidal effects within the dark matter halos of interest -- the effects of these processes can be highly degenerate with those of dark matter self-interactions at small scales. In this work we select 9 isolated galaxies and brightest cluster galaxies (BCGs) with baryonic components small enough such that the baryonic gravitational potentials do not significantly influence the halo gravothermal evolution processes. We then constrain the parameters of Rutherford and Moller scattering cross section models with the measured rotation curves and stellar kinematics through the gravothermal fluid formalism and isothermal method. Cross sections constrained by the two methods are consistent at $1σ$ confidence level, but the isothermal method prefers cross sections greater than the gravothermal approach constraints by a factor of $\sim3$.
△ Less
Submitted 26 April, 2024; v1 submitted 8 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
Lyman-α polarization from cosmological ionization fronts: I. Radiative transfer simulations
Authors:
Yuanyuan Yang,
Emily Koivu,
Chenxiao Zeng,
Heyang Long,
Christopher M. Hirata
Abstract:
In this paper, we present the formalism of simulating Lyman-$α$ emission and polarization around reionization ($z$ = 8) from a plane-parallel ionization front. We accomplish this by using a Monte Carlo method to simulate the production of a Lyman-$α$ photon, its propagation through an ionization front, and the eventual escape of this photon. This paper focuses on the relation of the input paramete…
▽ More
In this paper, we present the formalism of simulating Lyman-$α$ emission and polarization around reionization ($z$ = 8) from a plane-parallel ionization front. We accomplish this by using a Monte Carlo method to simulate the production of a Lyman-$α$ photon, its propagation through an ionization front, and the eventual escape of this photon. This paper focuses on the relation of the input parameters of ionization front speed $U$, blackbody temperature $T_{\rm bb}$, and neutral hydrogen density $n_{\rm HI}$, on intensity $I$ and polarized intensity $P$ as seen by a distant observer. The resulting values of intensity range from $3.18\times 10^{-14}$ erg/cm$^{2}$/s/sr to $1.96 \times 10^{-9}$ erg/cm$^{2}$/s/sr , and the polarized intensity ranges from $5.73\times 10^{-17}$ erg/cm$^{2}$/s/sr to $5.31 \times 10^{-12}$ erg/cm$^{2}$/s/sr. We found that higher $T_{\rm bb}$, higher $U$, and higher $n_{\rm HI}$ contribute to higher intensity, as well as polarized intensity, though the strongest dependence was on the hydrogen density. The dependence of viewing angle of the front is also explored. We present tests to support the validity model, which makes the model suitable for further use in a following paper where we will calculate the intensity and polarized intensity power spectrum on a full reionization simulation.
△ Less
Submitted 10 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
Self-calibrating optical galaxy cluster selection bias using cluster, galaxy, and shear cross-correlations
Authors:
Chenxiao Zeng,
Andrés N. Salcedo,
Hao-Yi Wu,
Christopher M. Hirata
Abstract:
The clustering signals of galaxy clusters are known to be powerful tools for self-calibrating the mass-observable relation and are complementary to cluster abundance and lensing. In this work, we explore the possibility of combining three correlation functions -- cluster lensing, the cluster-galaxy cross-correlation function, and the galaxy auto-correlation function -- to self-calibrate optical cl…
▽ More
The clustering signals of galaxy clusters are known to be powerful tools for self-calibrating the mass-observable relation and are complementary to cluster abundance and lensing. In this work, we explore the possibility of combining three correlation functions -- cluster lensing, the cluster-galaxy cross-correlation function, and the galaxy auto-correlation function -- to self-calibrate optical cluster selection bias, the boosted clustering and lensing signals in a richness-selected sample mainly caused by projection effects. We develop mock catalogues of redMaGiC-like galaxies and redMaPPer-like clusters by applying Halo Occupation Distribution (HOD) models to N-body simulations and using counts-in-cylinders around massive haloes as a richness proxy. In addition to the previously known small-scale boost in projected correlation functions, we find that the projection effects also significantly boost 3D correlation functions out to scales 100 $h^{-1} \mathrm{Mpc}$. We perform a likelihood analysis assuming survey conditions similar to that of the Dark Energy Survey (DES) and show that the selection bias can be self-consistently constrained at the 10% level. We discuss strategies for applying this approach to real data. We expect that expanding the analysis to smaller scales and using deeper lensing data would further improve the constraints on cluster selection bias.
△ Less
Submitted 3 July, 2023; v1 submitted 28 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
A multi-cubic-kilometre neutrino telescope in the western Pacific Ocean
Authors:
Z. P. Ye,
F. Hu,
W. Tian,
Q. C. Chang,
Y. L. Chang,
Z. S. Cheng,
J. Gao,
T. Ge,
G. H. Gong,
J. Guo,
X. X. Guo,
X. G. He,
J. T. Huang,
K. Jiang,
P. K. Jiang,
Y. P. Jing,
H. L. Li,
J. L. Li,
L. Li,
W. L. Li,
Z. Li,
N. Y. Liao,
Q. Lin,
F. Liu,
J. L. Liu
, et al. (33 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Next-generation neutrino telescopes with significantly improved sensitivity are required to pinpoint the sources of the diffuse astrophysical neutrino flux detected by IceCube and uncover the century-old puzzle of cosmic ray origins. A detector near the equator will provide a unique viewpoint of the neutrino sky, complementing IceCube and other neutrino telescopes in the Northern Hemisphere. Here…
▽ More
Next-generation neutrino telescopes with significantly improved sensitivity are required to pinpoint the sources of the diffuse astrophysical neutrino flux detected by IceCube and uncover the century-old puzzle of cosmic ray origins. A detector near the equator will provide a unique viewpoint of the neutrino sky, complementing IceCube and other neutrino telescopes in the Northern Hemisphere. Here we present results from an expedition to the north-eastern region of the South China Sea, in the western Pacific Ocean. A favorable neutrino telescope site was found on an abyssal plain at a depth of $\sim$ 3.5km. At depths below 3km, the sea current speed, water absorption and scattering lengths for Cherenkov light, were measured to be $v_{\mathrm{c}}<$10cm/s, $λ_{\mathrm{abs} }\simeq$ 27m and $λ_{\mathrm{sca} }\simeq$ 63m, respectively. Accounting for these measurements, we present the design and expected performance of a next-generation neutrino telescope, TRopIcal DEep-sea Neutrino Telescope (TRIDENT). With its advanced photon-detection technology and large dimensions, TRIDENT expects to observe the IceCube steady source candidate NGC 1068 with 5$σ$ significance within 1 year of operation. This level of sensitivity will open a new arena for diagnosing the origin of cosmic rays and probing fundamental physics over astronomical baselines.
△ Less
Submitted 13 May, 2024; v1 submitted 10 July, 2022;
originally announced July 2022.
-
A semi-analytic study of self-interacting dark-matter haloes with baryons
Authors:
Fangzhou Jiang,
Andrew Benson,
Philip F. Hopkins,
Oren Slone,
Mariangela Lisanti,
Manoj Kaplinghat,
Annika H. G. Peter,
Zhichao Carton Zeng,
Xiaolong Du,
Shengqi Yang,
Xuejian Shen
Abstract:
We combine the isothermal Jeans model and the model of adiabatic halo contraction into a simple semi-analytic procedure for computing the density profile of self-interacting dark-matter (SIDM) haloes with the gravitational influence from the inhabitant galaxies. We show that the model agrees well with cosmological SIDM simulations over the entire core-forming stage and up to the onset of gravother…
▽ More
We combine the isothermal Jeans model and the model of adiabatic halo contraction into a simple semi-analytic procedure for computing the density profile of self-interacting dark-matter (SIDM) haloes with the gravitational influence from the inhabitant galaxies. We show that the model agrees well with cosmological SIDM simulations over the entire core-forming stage and up to the onset of gravothermal core-collapse. Using this model, we show that the halo response to baryons is more diverse in SIDM than in CDM and depends sensitively on galaxy size, a desirable link in the context of the structural diversity of bright dwarf galaxies. The fast speed of the method facilitates analyses that would be challenging for numerical simulations -- notably, 1) we quantify the SIDM halo response as functions of the baryonic properties, on a fine mesh grid spanned by the baryon-to-total-mass ratio, $M_{\rm b}/M_{\rm vir}$, and galaxy compactness, $r_{1/2}/R_{\rm vir}$; 2) we show with high statistical precision that for typical Milky-Way-like systems, the SIDM profiles are similar to their CDM counterparts; and 3) we delineate the regime of gravothermal core-collapse in the $M_{\rm b}/M_{\rm vir}$-$r_{1/2}/R_{\rm vir}$ space, for a given cross section and a given halo concentration. Finally, we compare the isothermal Jeans model with the more sophisticated gravothermal fluid model, and show that the former yields faster core formation and agrees better with cosmological simulations. We attribute the difference to whether the target CDM halo is used as a boundary condition or as the initial condition for the gravothermal evolution, and thus comment on possible future improvements of the fluid model. We have made our programs for the model publicly available at https://github.com/JiangFangzhou/SIDM.
△ Less
Submitted 24 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
Gravothermal solutions of SIDM halos: mapping from constant to velocity-dependent cross section
Authors:
Shengqi Yang,
Xiaolong Du,
Zhichao Carton Zeng,
Andrew Benson,
Fangzhou Jiang,
Ethan O. Nadler,
Annika H. G. Peter
Abstract:
The scale-free gravothermal fluid formalism has long proved effective in describing the evolution of self-interacting dark matter halos with a constant dark matter particle cross section. However, whether the gravothermal fluid solutions match numerical simulations for velocity-dependent cross-section scenarios remains untested. In this work, we provide a fast mapping method that relates the const…
▽ More
The scale-free gravothermal fluid formalism has long proved effective in describing the evolution of self-interacting dark matter halos with a constant dark matter particle cross section. However, whether the gravothermal fluid solutions match numerical simulations for velocity-dependent cross-section scenarios remains untested. In this work, we provide a fast mapping method that relates the constant-cross-section gravothermal solution to models with arbitrary velocity dependence in the cross section. We show that the gravothermal solutions after mapping are in good agreement with Arepo N-Body simulation results. We illustrate the power of this approach by applying this fast mapping method to a halo hosting a low surface brightness galaxy UGC 128. We show that this fast mapping method can be used to constrain free parameters in a physically motivated cross-section model and illustrate parameter space favored by the rotation curve measurement.
△ Less
Submitted 2 March, 2023; v1 submitted 5 May, 2022;
originally announced May 2022.
-
Optical selection bias and projection effects in stacked galaxy cluster weak lensing
Authors:
Hao-Yi Wu,
Matteo Costanzi,
Chun-Hao To,
Andrés N. Salcedo,
David H. Weinberg,
James Annis,
Sebastian Bocquet,
Maria Elidaiana da Silva Pereira,
Joseph DeRose,
Johnny Esteves,
Arya Farahi,
Sebastian Grandis,
Eduardo Rozo,
Eli S. Rykoff,
Tamás N. Varga,
Risa H. Wechsler,
Chenxiao Zeng,
Yuanyuan Zhang,
Zhuowen Zhang
Abstract:
Cosmological constraints from current and upcoming galaxy cluster surveys are limited by the accuracy of cluster mass calibration. In particular, optically identified galaxy clusters are prone to selection effects that can bias the weak lensing mass calibration. We investigate the selection bias of the stacked cluster lensing signal associated with optically selected clusters, using clusters ident…
▽ More
Cosmological constraints from current and upcoming galaxy cluster surveys are limited by the accuracy of cluster mass calibration. In particular, optically identified galaxy clusters are prone to selection effects that can bias the weak lensing mass calibration. We investigate the selection bias of the stacked cluster lensing signal associated with optically selected clusters, using clusters identified by the redMaPPer algorithm in the Buzzard simulations as a case study. We find that at a given cluster halo mass, the residuals of redMaPPer richness and weak lensing signal are positively correlated. As a result, for a given richness selection, the stacked lensing signal is biased high compared with what we would expect from the underlying halo mass probability distribution. The cluster lensing selection bias can thus lead to overestimated mean cluster mass and biased cosmology results. We show that the lensing selection bias exhibits a strong scale-dependence and is approximately 20 to 60 percent for $ΔΣ$ at large scales. This selection bias largely originates from spurious member galaxies within +/- 20 to 60 Mpc/h along the line of sight, highlighting the importance of quantifying projection effects associated with the broad redshift distribution of member galaxies in photometric cluster surveys. While our results qualitatively agree with those in the literature, accurate quantitative modelling of the selection bias is needed to achieve the goals of cluster lensing cosmology and will require synthetic catalogues covering a wide range of galaxy-halo connection models.
△ Less
Submitted 9 August, 2022; v1 submitted 10 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Core-collapse, evaporation and tidal effects: the life story of a self-interacting dark matter subhalo
Authors:
Zhichao Carton Zeng,
Annika H. G. Peter,
Xiaolong Du,
Andrew Benson,
Stacy Kim,
Fangzhou Jiang,
Francis-Yan Cyr-Racine,
Mark Vogelsberger
Abstract:
Self-interacting dark matter (SIDM) cosmologies admit an enormous diversity of dark matter (DM) halo density profiles, from low-density cores to high-density core-collapsed cusps. The possibility of the growth of high central density in low-mass halos, accelerated if halos are subhalos of larger systems, has intriguing consequences for small-halo searches with substructure lensing. However, follow…
▽ More
Self-interacting dark matter (SIDM) cosmologies admit an enormous diversity of dark matter (DM) halo density profiles, from low-density cores to high-density core-collapsed cusps. The possibility of the growth of high central density in low-mass halos, accelerated if halos are subhalos of larger systems, has intriguing consequences for small-halo searches with substructure lensing. However, following the evolution of $\lesssim 10^8 M_\odot$ subhalos in lens-mass systems ($\sim 10^{13}M_\odot$) is computationally expensive with traditional N-body simulations. In this work, we develop a new hybrid semi-analytical + N-body method to study the evolution of SIDM subhalos with high fidelity, from core formation to core-collapse, in staged simulations. Our method works best for small subhalos ($\lesssim 1/1000$ host mass), for which the error caused by dynamical friction is minimal. We are able to capture the evaporation of subhalo particles by interactions with host halo particles, an effect that has not yet been fully explored in the context of subhalo core-collapse. We find three main processes drive subhalo evolution: subhalo internal heat outflow, host-subhalo evaporation, and tidal effects. The subhalo central density grows only when the heat outflow outweighs the energy gain from evaporation and tidal heating. Thus, evaporation delays or even disrupts subhalo core-collapse. We map out the parameter space for subhalos to core-collapse, finding that it is nearly impossible to drive core-collapse in subhalos in SIDM models with constant cross sections. Any discovery of ultra-compact dark substructures with future substructure lensing observations favors additional degrees of freedom, such as velocity-dependence, in the cross section.
△ Less
Submitted 22 August, 2022; v1 submitted 1 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Non-equilibrium temperature evolution of ionization fronts during the Epoch of Reionization
Authors:
Chenxiao Zeng,
Christopher M. Hirata
Abstract:
The epoch of reionization (EoR) marks the end of the Cosmic Dawn and the beginning of large-scale structure formation in the universe. The impulsive ionization fronts (I-fronts) heat and ionize the gas within the reionization bubbles in the intergalactic medium (IGM). The temperature during this process is a key yet uncertain ingredient in current models. Typically, reionization simulations assume…
▽ More
The epoch of reionization (EoR) marks the end of the Cosmic Dawn and the beginning of large-scale structure formation in the universe. The impulsive ionization fronts (I-fronts) heat and ionize the gas within the reionization bubbles in the intergalactic medium (IGM). The temperature during this process is a key yet uncertain ingredient in current models. Typically, reionization simulations assume that all baryonic species are in instantaneous thermal equilibrium with each other during the passage of an I-front. Here we present a new model of the temperature evolution for the ionization front by studying non-equilibrium effects. In particular, we include the energy transfer between major baryon species ($e^{-}$, \HI, \HII, \HeI, and \HeII) and investigate their impacts on the post-ionization front temperature $T_{\mathrm{re}}$. For a better step-size control when solving the stiff equations, we implement an implicit method and construct an energy transfer rate matrix. We find that the assumption of equilibration is valid for a low-speed ionization front ($\lessapprox\ 10^9~\mathrm{cm}/\mathrm{s}$), but deviations from equilibrium occur for faster fronts. The post-front temperature $T_{\mathrm{re}}$ is lower by up to 19.7\% (at $3\times 10^9$ cm/s) or 30.8\% (at $10^{10}$ cm/s) relative to the equilibrium case.
△ Less
Submitted 6 July, 2020;
originally announced July 2020.
-
Searching for Oscillations in the Primordial Power Spectrum with CMB and LSS Data
Authors:
Chenxiao Zeng,
Ely D. Kovetz,
Xuelei Chen,
Yan Gong,
Julian B. Muñoz,
Marc Kamionkowski
Abstract:
Different inflationary models predict oscillatory features in the primordial power spectrum. These can leave an imprint on both the cosmic microwave background (CMB) and the large-scale structure (LSS) of our Universe, that can be searched for with current data. Inspired by the axion-monodromy model of inflation, we search for primordial oscillations that are logarithmic in wavenumber, using both…
▽ More
Different inflationary models predict oscillatory features in the primordial power spectrum. These can leave an imprint on both the cosmic microwave background (CMB) and the large-scale structure (LSS) of our Universe, that can be searched for with current data. Inspired by the axion-monodromy model of inflation, we search for primordial oscillations that are logarithmic in wavenumber, using both CMB data from the Planck satellite and LSS data from the WiggleZ galaxy survey. We find that, within our search range for the new oscillation parameters (amplitude, frequency and phase), both CMB-only and CMB+LSS data yield the same best-fit oscillation frequency of $\log_{10}ω=1.5$, improving the fit over $Λ$CDM by $Δχ^2\! =\! -9$ and $Δχ^2\! =\! -13$ (roughly corresponding to $2σ$ and $2.8σ$ significance), respectively. Bayesian evidence for the log-oscillation model versus $Λ$CDM indicates a very slight preference for the latter. Future CMB and LSS data will further probe this scenario.
△ Less
Submitted 13 February, 2019; v1 submitted 12 December, 2018;
originally announced December 2018.
