Talk:Dhu al-Shamalayn

Latest comment: 2 years ago by 101.167.226.213 in topic already dead at time of hadith

already dead at time of hadith

edit

In the Nisai hadith, it says that (presumably the same) Dhu al-Shamalayn corrected the Prophet as to the number of rackat performed. This hadith was narrated by Abu Huraira, and in the Bukhari version, Abu Huraira clearly indicated he was there (saying The Prophet "led us in one of the two `Isha' prayers"). If Bukhari is to be believed - then it cannot be authentic - since Dhu al-Shamalayn died in 624AH (battle of Badr), and Abu Huraira did not become one The Prophet's companions for another 5 years or so. He could not have been at prayer at the same time as Dhu al-Shamalayn 101.167.226.213 (talk) 03:43, 13 September 2022 (UTC)Reply